Schubert: Hyperion Song Edition 34 – Schubert 1817-1821

Recording details: January 1999 Rosslyn Hill Unitarian Chapel, Hampstead, London, United Kingdom Produced by Various producers Engineered by Antony Howell & Julian Millard Another fascinating Schubertiad, this time comprising songs from the period 1817 to 1821. As before, it contains some familiar masterpieces, some unknown masterpieces, rarities and fragments, many of them receiving their first recording. Particularly fetching are the Singübungen—a wordless singing exercise for two sopranos, and Über allen Zauber Liebe (‘Love above all magic’) which, of all the Schubert fragments, is the most alluring. (Only four bars of music were needed to complete the setting and if the composer had provided the missing bars himself, and the piece subsequently published, it is hard to imagine what could have prevented the song from being known throughout the world, treasured and hummed by connoisseurs.) Various volumes in the Hyperion Schubert Edition have dealt with these five years in the composer’s life in greater detail than this short overview will permit. There is an essay about the years 1817/18 accompanying Volume 21 where Edith Mathis sings lieder from that period. Similarly, the period 1819/20 is covered by Volume 29 (Marjana Lipovšek and Nathan Berg) and 1821/22 by Volume 28 (John Mark Ainsley and Maarten Koningsberger). For the earlier periods of the composer’s life, Volumes 12 and 33 are devoted to the period 1810 to 1814; Volumes 7, 10, 20 and 22 to 1815; Volumes 17, 23 and 32 to 1816. Volume 26 is given over to the songs of the year 1826. There will be surveys of the period 1823-1825 in Volume 35, 1827 in Volume 36, and finally 1828 in Volume 37. In this way the booklets, taken together and not in the order of their issue, offer a commentary on the composer’s whole creative life. 1815 and 1816 were by far Schubert’s most prolific years in terms of the number of songs he composed. Following this period of brilliant adolescence, we begin with 1817 when the composer met his first (and by many accounts, greatest) contemporary interpreter, Johann Michael Vogl, and won him to his cause. Schubert was on the threshold of manhood, but still young and highly impressionable, and we traverse many lieder landscapes to greet the maturity and mastery of a man of 24, the Schubert of the ‘symphonic’ songs of 1821, the young composer now famous in Vienna, published, and certain of an important opera commission. These were the final years of the composer’s struggle to achieve independence from his father (and freedom from the duties of the schoolroom); they include his richest engagement with songs of classical mythology, and his closest association with the poet Mayrhofer, as well as his work on a number of poets whose influence is very much part of his middle years (Schreiber, the Schlegel brothers, Novalis, Silbert). In 1821 there is a return to a new Goethe, the recent poet of the West-Östlicher Divan, and Schubert’s penultimate engagement with the elusive lyrics of Wilhelm Meister. Through all this period we note the intellectual and emotional influence of the composer’s closest friend, Franz von Schober. The following summations of each year’s activity are meant to give the listener some idea of the context, biographical and musical, in which the works to be heard on this disc were composed. 1817 Schubert’s first meeting with Johann Michael Vogl. Schubert leaves the school house and moves in with Franz Schober until August when Schober has to leave Vienna [Abschied von einem Freunde (Schubert) D578]. He is forced to return to the parental home. Deepening friendship with Johann Mayrhofer. Josef Hüttenbrenner becomes a self-appointed Schubert publicist. ‘It is arguable that an anthology of great songs from 1817 would better represent Schubert’s versatile lyrical genius than any other year of his life.’ (John Reed) Lieder: 69 songs, including eighteen to texts of Mayrhofer including Der Alpenjäger D524, Wie Ulfru fischt D525, Fahrt zum Hades D526, Memnon D541, Der Schiffer D536, Atys D585, Erlafsee D586. Frohsinn (Castelli) D520, Der Tod und das Mädchen (Claudius) D531, Die Nacht (Macpherson/Ossian/Harold) D534, Der Jüngling und der Tod (Spaun) D545, An die Musik (Schober) D547, Die Forelle (Schubart) D550, Die Einsiedelei (Salis-Seewis) D563. Auf dem See (Goethe) D543, Ganymed (Goethe), D544; Liebhaber in allen Gestalten (Goethe) D558, Gruppe aus dem Tartarus (Schiller) D583, Der Kampf (Schiller) D594. Partsongs include: La pastorella al prato (Goldoni) D513, Das Grab (Salis-Seewis) D569, Das Dörfchen (Bürger) D598. Other works: piano sonatas, all composed between March and August (A minor D537, A flat D557, E minor D566, D flat D567, E flat D568, B major D575.) The Sonata in A for violin and piano (‘Duo’) D574. Symphony No 6 in C major D589 begun in October; Overtures in D and C ‘in the Italian Style’ D590 and D591, November 1817. 1818 The Schubert family move to the Rossau where the composer was probably temporarily constrained to return to teaching. Erlafsee (see 1817) was published as a supplement to the Mahlerisches Taschenbuch – the first Schubert song to appear in print in any form. The first Overture in the Italian Style is the first work of Schubert to achieve public performance. Summer residency in Zseliz (Hungary) as music-master to the daughters of Count Esterházy. Not only songs and singing exercises but also piano duets are written for the family. On his return from Hungary in October, Schubert moves in with the poet Mayrhofer whom he had known since 1814. He is commissioned by the Kärntnertor Theatre (through the good offices of Vogl) to write the opera Die Zwillingsbrüder which would eventually be produced in 1820. Of all the years in Schubert’s working life this was the least productive in terms of number of works. It was a turning-point in the composer’s life, the period when he seems to have spent a lot of time agonising about his future, refusing to return to the schoolhouse to fulfil his father’s wishes. Lieder: 15 songs including Auf der Riesenkoppe (Körner) D611, An den Mond in einer Herbstnacht (Schreiber) D614. During the summer in Zseliz: Einsamkeit (Mayrhofer) D620, Das Abendrot (Schreiber) D627, Sing-Übungen D619. Sonnett I, II & III (Petrarch, trans. A W von Schlegel) D628, 629, and (trans. Gries) D630, Blanka (Schlegel) D631, Vom Mitleiden Mariä (Schlegel) D632. Partsong: Die Geselligkeit (Unger) D609. Other works: Rondo in D for four hands, D608, Sonata in B flat for four hands D617, Deutsches Requiem (Schmid) in G minor D621, Piano Sonata in F minor D625. 1819 During the whole of this year Schubert shares Mayrhofer’s tiny apartment in the Wipplingerstrasse. The cramped conditions of a very small room meant that there was probably an arrangement whereby the composer worked during the mornings (when Mayrhofer was at the censor’s office) and absented himself in the afternoons permitting the poet to write during these hours. The first Schubert song to be performed in public is Schäfers Klagelied (Goethe) D121 at the ‘Roman Emperor’ Inn on 28 February. The composer is much occupied with the score for Die Zwillingsbrüder for which he is paid 180 florins by the Court Theatre. In early July (and until mid-September) Schubert goes on holiday with Johann Michael Vogl in Steyr, a town in Upper Austria where he will return in two subsequent summers (1823 and 1825). The singer’s birthday is celebrated with a special cantata in his honour. Lieder: 24 songs and one fragment including: settings of Friedrich von Schlegel: Der Schmetterling D633 and four other songs (Das Mädchen D652, Die Berge D634, Die Gebüsche D646 and Der Wanderer D649) from the Abendröte cycle. Abend (Tieck) D645 fragment, Abendbilder (Silbert) D650, Hymne I, II, III & IV (Novalis) D659, 660. 661, 662. Mayrhofer settings: Beim Winde D669, Die Sternennächte D670, Trost D671, Nachtstück D672. Goethe settings: Die Liebende schreibt D673, Prometheus D674. Die Götter Griechenlands (Schiller) D6771. Partsongs: Kantate zum Geburtstag des Sängers Johann Michael Vogl (Stadler) D666 Other works: Die Zwillingsbrüder – Singspiel in one act (D647), Piano Sonata in A D664 (if not 1825), Quintet in A major D667 (Forellenquintett), Salve Regina in A D676, Mass in A flat D678. Work on the opera fragment Adrast D137 with a text by Mayrhofer. 1820 One of the biggest undertakings of the year is the oratorio Lazarus which is begun in January. This work ranks as one of Schubert’s most experimental scores where he seems to anticipate the thematic practices of Wagner. The composer is arrested (with Bruchmann and other members of the circle) during a police raid on the rooms of Johann Senn. He is released, but Senn is imprisoned and committed to trial, the result of which was an order restricting him to his native Tyrol. The opera Die Zwillingsbrüder is produced at the Kärntnertor Theatre in June and runs for six performances. In August the ‘Zauberspiel’ Die Zauberharfe receives eight performances. In terms of theatrical success this is the (rather muted) high point of Schubert’s life; he would never have another opera played in a theatre during his lifetime. The composer spends his first sojourn at Atzenbrugg castle just outside Vienna (see cover illustration, dating from this year); this was to be a summer gathering point for the Schubertians for the next few years. The success of a public performance of Erlkönig (Goethe) D138 in December leads to a plan to publish Schubert songs privately. Schubert decides to live on his own at the end of the year, leaving Mayrhofer with whom he had shared a small room for some two years – the longest period that he was ever to occupy a single address in Vienna, apart from his parental home. Lieder: 20 songs and a fragment including settings of Friedrich von Schlegel from Abendröte: Die Sterne D684, Abendröte D690, Die Vögel D691, Der Knabe D692, Der Fluss D693, Der Schiffer D694, all in Volume 27. Im Walde D708. Frühlingsglaube (Uhland) D686, Nachthymne (Novalis) D687, both in Volume 29. Settings of Mayrhofer: Über allen Zauber Liebe (fragment) D682, Der entsühnte Orest D699, Freiwilliges Versinken D700, Der zürnenden Diana D707, all in Volume 14 apart from the fragment on this disc. Partsongs: Gesang der Geister über den Wassern for TTBB and piano (Goethe) D705, Der 23. Psalm D706. Other works: Lazarus – ‘Szenisches Oratorium’ (Niemeyer) D689, Die Zauberharfe (Hofmann), a magic play with music in 3 acts, D644. 1821 At the beginning of the year Schubert applies for a post as a repetiteur at the Kärntnertor Theatre, a job which does not suit him (he coaches the soprano Karoline Unger; see note in connection with Die Geselligkeit on this disc). At the end of January there is a big musical party at Schober’s which may have been the first ever Schubertiad as such. A concert at the Kärntnertor Theatre where Erlkönig is sung by Vogl (not accompanied by the composer) makes Schubert an overnight success with the Viennese public in a way that he had never before experienced. Erlkönig is published by Cappi and Diabelli as Opus 1 in April. Das Dörfchen (on this disc) also enjoys a large public success. Once again the summer is spent in Atzenbrugg, and in the autumn the composer goes with Schober to St. Pölten, Lower Austria, to work intensively on the opera Alfonso und Estrella. The composer has an overture (in E minor) included in a Philharmonic Society concert in November. With his hopes high for the success of his large opera, and with many ‘firsts’ to look back on in 1821, we may judge this to be the period when Schubert felt that he was at last on the ‘right track’. Disappointment was to follow at the beginning of 1822 (concerning the fate of the opera), and tragedy was to strike, changing the composer’s life forever, at the end of that year. Lieder: 10 (possibly 11) songs, and 2 fragments including Die gefangenen Sänger (August von Schlegel) D712, Der Unglückliche (Pichler) D713. Settings of Goethe: Versunken D715, Grenzen der Menschheit D716, Geheimes D719, Suleika I D720, Mignon (‘Heiss mich nicht reden’) first setting D726, Mignon (‘So lasst mich scheinen’), second setting D727. The date of Suleika II D717 is uncertain (perhaps 1824). Another song of uncertain date is Wandrers Nachtlied II D768. It could have been written as early as 1821 which, after all, is a year rich in Goethe settings, but it is usually placed at the end of 1822 with Schubert’s final batch of Goethe songs. Even if it is an 1822 song (or even later) it makes an appropriate end to this disc, bringing the list of Goethe songs recorded in the Hyperion Schubert Edition to a close. Partsong: Im Gegenwärtigen Vergangenes (Goethe) D710. Other works: Gesang der Geister über den Wassern (Goethe) for male voice octet and strings D714, two supplementary numbers for Hérold’s opera Das Zauberglöckchen D723 and Alfonso und Estrella (Schober) opera in three acts D732. Graham Johnson © 2000